Book Review

The Third Man by Graham Greene

reading the script of a very acclaimed film...

I read this cute little paperback I got from the second hand bookstore that’s adjacent to the Bluecoat Gallery in Liverpool, when I was there over the Christmas period…

The Third Man is of course not a novel, it’s a film, and famously one of the best films, directed by Carol Reed (who also directed the Obi Wan Kenobi version of Our Man In Havana (the one filmed in Castro’s newly revolutionised Cuba) and the musical Oliver!, among many other films, though no others I’ve personally seen), and starring Orson Welles and other people who aren’t famous any more…

This book, published by Faber and Faber though seemingly produced (this edition at least) as a free gift for subscribers to Sight and Sound (the British Film Institute’s long-running magazine), is difficult to date from the copyright page – there are so many years mentioned there that it’s difficult to know when and how this script – for this is what it is – was first made available for the reading public. 1968? 1974? The Revised Edition from 1984?

What we do know, then, is that the film was released in 1949, and that the script contained here is a combination of the manuscript Graham Greene handed off to the production company, as well as the shooting script Carol Reed had for the shoot when it began, and also the final edited version of the film, with this book therefore attempting to convey a) cuts made to Greene’s script prior to shooting, b) improvised or amended lines as spoken on set (essentially Orson Welles seemed to not really believe in other people’s ability to write, which is fair enough as the improvised lines (included as footnotes here) are – if not the most effective – often the most memorable, the most poetic (e.g. this line about peace and cuckoo clocks)) and c) decisions made in the editing suite…

This does lead, then, to a little bit of a mess on the page, with unclear footnotes and an overuse of square brackets, and repeated corrections given for recurring changes that were made to the script, such as – the key one – character names being different to Greene’s initial plan.

There are also issues with typesetting, lines of print being duplicated at different font sizes, and a couple of misprints that one wouldn’t normally associate with Faber…

This, then, is a lovely shoddy paperback.

It’s a lovely shoddy paperback copy of a script of a noir about a shoddy man who’s done shoddy deals, causing (spoilers for the 1949 film The Third Man follow) death and illness by not just profiteering off medical supplies in post-war Vienna, but adulterating and watering down the price-gouged medication to the point where it became ineffective…

I love this little pocket sized paperback, and I read the majority of this script on a single tube journey, crouched in the corner of a carriage between my adorable dog and a large fancy-looking though very crumpled bag that contained a cake I’d received that day as a late holiday gift…

I was glued to the page, flicking through Greene’s narrative, even though I’ve seen this film before and I’ve seen other noir films and I’ve read loaddds of noir narratives, so I know how these things go and how these things end…..

But it’s fucking gripping.

The Third Man is serious and it’s sad and it’s funny and it’s fucking serious and it’s fucking sad and it’s a howling fucking pleasure to read.

Highly recommended, tbh. Though I do like a bit of Greene!!!

–///–

Have just read about a few more of Carol Reed’s films that I haven’t seen, and though several sound fucking tedious (e.g. Charlton Heston is Michaelangelo), a couple of the other thrillery noirs he made around The Third Man sound very fucking watchable.

Guess I know what I’ll be googling when I settle in for another solo Saturday night this weekend…


Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Thank you so much for reading TriumphoftheNow.com! If you like what you’ve read, please subscribe, share and order one of my books. If you love what you’ve read, why not order me something frivolous and noisy from this Amazon wishlist or make a quick donation via my ko-fi page?

I’m currently focusing on parenting and creative practice, so small donations are appreciated now more than ever!


scott manley hadley aka SOLID BALD live

Here’s a video of me recently performing at the prestigious (it has a Wikipedia page) comedy night, Quantum Leopard. Listen to how much fun the crowd is having. You could have that much fun, too!

Forthcoming gigs include the following – there may/will be others:

18th February 2026, 7.30pm: Laughable, Wanstead Library

26th February 2026: Mirth Control, Bexhill-on-Sea

12th March 2025: BALD PERSONALITY DISORDER 30 MIN WIP at Glasgow International Comedy Festival

26th March 2026, 7.30pm: Comedy @ Cosmic, Plymouth

May 2026: BALD PERSONALITY DISORDER FULL LENGTH WIP at the BRIGHTON FRINGE


Discover more from Triumph Of The Now

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 comments on “The Third Man by Graham Greene

  1. Unknown's avatar

    i love this book (and the film it is based on) One of my favourite bits is a classic piece of Greene xenophobia that I reckon made him laugh like a drain for several days. When Anna is about to be arrested and needs to get dressed, Greene takes great pride in describing the actions of each occupying nations police officer. The puritanical American leaves the room, the slightly more practical but equally prudish Briton stays in the room, but turns away from the girl. The Russian officer stares, but without a hint of emotion or lust in his terrifying Commie face and the French officer lights a cigarette and enjoys the show.

    Liked by 1 person

    • scottmanleyhadley's avatar

      Yes, that’s a very Greene scene… I feel like a lot of his novels sound a bit like a very sad joke that opens with “an Englishman, a Frenchman and an American walk into a brothel…”

      Like

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Discover more from Triumph Of The Now

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading